A question we get constantly
The Piedmont is full of brick. Brick ranches through south Guilford and Pleasant Garden, brick two-storeys in Irving Park and Buena Vista, brick and stone combinations across every subdivision built since the 1980s.
And painted brick has been fashionable for a decade now, so we get asked about it most weeks.
Our honest answer is usually: think harder about it than you would about any other painting decision you will make. Not because it cannot be done well — it can — but because it is the one exterior decision that is effectively permanent.
It is close to irreversible
Unpainted brick can be painted. Painted brick cannot realistically be returned to bare brick.
Stripping paint from masonry is slow, expensive, and frequently damages the face of the brick in the process, because the coating has keyed into a porous surface rather than sitting on a smooth one. Chemical strippers and media blasting both risk taking the hard fired outer skin off with the paint, which leaves a softer, more absorbent surface than you started with.
So the realistic options after painting are: keep it painted, or replace the masonry. Plan on the first.
The moisture problem is the real one
This is the part that gets discussed least and matters most.
A brick wall is not a sealed surface, and it is not supposed to be. Brick and mortar absorb water and release it again as they dry. That cycle is how the wall stays sound.
An ordinary film-forming exterior paint is designed to keep water out — which sounds like exactly what you want, and on wood siding it is. On masonry it means moisture that gets into the wall from elsewhere, and it always does, through the top, through the mortar joints, through rain driven against it, through the ground, now cannot get back out through the face.
What follows is spalling: trapped moisture, particularly with a freeze-thaw cycle like ours, pushes the face off the brick. You get flaking paint with pieces of brick face attached to it, and the damage underneath is permanent.
The answer is not to skip the paint. It is to use a breathable, vapour-permeable masonry coating rather than a standard exterior wall paint, and to deal with whatever is letting water into the wall first. A contractor who quotes brick with the same product they use on siding has not thought about it.
You are also signing up for a maintenance cycle
Bare brick is close to zero-maintenance. It weathers, it does not fail.
Painted brick is a coating, and coatings have a service life. You are converting a wall that needed nothing into a wall that needs repainting on a cycle — and repainting masonry is not a cheap job, because the surface area is large and the preparation on a previously painted wall is more involved than on new brick.
That is a legitimate trade to make for a look you want. It should just be a decision you made deliberately rather than one you discover in eight years.
Where it genuinely makes sense
We are not against it, and there are cases where it is clearly the right call.
Brick that has already been painted by a previous owner, where the only question is what goes on next. Mismatched masonry from an addition or a repair that will never blend. Brick that has been badly patched, or that has had a failed sealer applied to it. And plenty of houses where the brick colour simply fights everything else and always will.
In those situations the decision is already made or the alternative is worse, and a proper breathable system on a properly prepared wall will look excellent and last.
The alternatives worth knowing
Limewash and mineral coatings. These soak into the masonry rather than forming a film over it, stay highly breathable, and weather by softening rather than peeling. The look is more mottled and less uniform than paint, which some people want and some do not. They are worth understanding before defaulting to paint.
Paint the trim instead. This is our most common recommendation on Triad brick ranches, and it is usually what people actually wanted. Fascia, soffit, window and door trim, porch posts and ceilings, shutters and the garage door carry most of the visual weight of one of these houses. Changing those changes the house dramatically, costs a fraction of coating the masonry, and commits you to nothing.
A surprising number of people arrive asking about painting their brick and leave having booked the trim, because once they see it drawn out that way it was the answer all along.
How we will handle the conversation
We will quote it if you want it, using a breathable system and after dealing with any moisture source we can see. We will also tell you plainly if we think you are about to spend money on something you will regret, because we would rather lose one job than be the company that painted your brick badly.
If you are weighing it up, call us on 336-207-1159 and we will come and look at the actual wall before anyone gives you a number.